|
By Elizabeth Rubin
For more than 30 years, the Mujahedeen Khalq, or People's Mujahedeen,
has survived and operated on the margins of history and the slivers
of land that Saddam Hussein and French governments have proffered
it. During the 1970's, while it was still an underground Iranian
political movement, you could encounter some of its members on
the streets of New York, waving pictures of torture victims of
the shah's regime. In the 80's and 90's, after its leaders fled
Iran, you could see them raising money and petitioning on university
campuses around the United States, pumping photographs in the
air of women mangled and tortured by the Islamic regime in Tehran.
By then, they were also showing off other photographs, photographs
that were in some ways more attention-grabbing: Iranian women
in military uniforms who brandished guns, drove tanks and were
ready to overthrow the Iranian government. Led by a charismatic
husband-and-wife duo, Maryam and Massoud Rajavi, the Mujahedeen
had transformed itself into the only army in the world with a
commander corps composed mostly of women.
Until the United States invaded Iraq in March, the Mujahedeen
survived for two decades under the patronage of Saddam Hussein.
He gave the group money, weapons, jeeps and military bases along
the Iran-Iraq border -- a convenient launching ground for its
attacks against Iranian government figures. When U.S. forces
toppled Saddam's regime, they were not sure how to handle the
army of some 5,000 Mujahedeen fighters, many of them female and
all of them fanatically loyal to the Rajavis. The U.S soldiers'
confusion reflected confusion back home. The Mujahedeen has a
sophisticated lobbying apparatus, and it has exploited the notion
of female soldiers fighting the Islamic clerical rulers in Tehran
to garner the support of dozens in Congress. But the group is
also on the State Department's list of foreign terrorist organizations,
placed there in 1997 as a goodwill gesture toward Iran's newly
elected reform-minded president, Mohammad Khatami.
With the fall of Saddam and with a wave of antigovernment
demonstrations across Iran last month, the Mujahedeen suddenly
found itself thrown into the middle of Washington's foreign-policy
battles over what to do about Iran. And now its fate hangs precariously
between extinction and resurrection. A number of Pentagon hawks
and policy makers are advocating that the Mujahedeen be removed
from the terrorist list and recycled for future use against Iran.
But the French have also stepped into the Persian fray on the
side of the Iranian government -- who consider the Rajavis and
their army a mortal enemy. In the early-morning hours of June
17, some 1,300 French police officers descended upon the town
of Auvers-sur-Oise, where the Mujahedeen established its political
headquarters. After offering the Iranian exiles sanctuary on
and off for two decades and providing police protection to Maryam
Rajavi, the French mysteriously arrested Rajavi along with 160
of her followers, claiming that the group was planning to move
its military base to France and launch terrorist attacks on Iranian
targets in Europe. Immediately, zealous Mujahedeen members in
Paris, London and Rome staged hunger strikes, demanding the release
of Maryam, and several set themselves ablaze.
In Washington, Senator Sam Brownback, Republican of Kansas
and chairman of the Foreign Relations subcommittee on South Asia,
accused the French of doing the Iranian government's dirty work.
Along with other members of Congress, Brownback wrote a letter
of protest to President Jacques Chirac, while longtime Mujahedeen
champions like Sheila Jackson-Lee, Democrat of Texas, expressed
their distress over Maryam's arrest. But few, if any, of these
supporters have visited the Mujahedeen's desert encampments in
Iraq and know how truly bizarre this revolutionary group is.
ecently, I went to visit Camp Ashraf, the main Mujahedeen
base, which lies some 65 miles north of Baghdad in Diala province,
near the Iranian border. Ashraf is 14 square miles of ungenerous
desert surrounded by aprons of barbed wire, gun towers and guards
in trough-like bunkers, shaded by camouflage netting and dehydrated
palm trees, their trunks thickened by dust. As you pass the checkpoints
and dragons'-teeth tire crunchers into the tidy military town,
you feel you've entered a fictional world of female worker bees.
Of course, there are men around; about 50 percent of the soldiers
are male. But everywhere I turned, I saw women dressed in khaki
uniforms and mud-colored head scarves, driving back and forth
along the avenues in white pickups or army-green trucks, staring
ahead, slightly dazed, or walking purposefully, a slight march
to their gaits as at a factory in Maoist China.
Pari Bahshai, a stocky Iranian woman in her mid-40's and the
military commander of Ashraf, was my tour guide for the day.
We drove through the grounds in her white Land Cruiser out to
a dry, burning plain where dozens of young women were buried
in the mouths of their tanks -- adjusting, winching, tinkering
with the circuits and engines that keep their fighting machines
alive. There were neat rows of Brazilian Cascavel tanks, Russian
BMP armored vehicles and British Chieftains, most of them captured
from Iran at the end of the Iran-Iraq war.
Some of the women smiled shyly; others were expressionless
as Bahshai -- who was tough but indulgent and whom they clearly
loved -- made her introductions. ''When they first come here,
it's hard for them to deal with these armored vehicles,'' she
said. ''They don't believe in themselves. They think only men
can do it. But as they see the others, they overcome their insecurity.
I went through this process myself.'' Hossein Madani, a Mujahedeen
political spokesman who was my minder for the day, said, ''These
young women are all new from Iran or countries abroad.''
One by one, the youngest Mujahedeen sprang to life to recite
their stories. A dark-haired beauty blurted out fast and robotically
in Farsi, with a comrade translating into English: ''I came from
Tehran six months ago. I'm 20 years old. I was in a very unstable
psychological situation in the last days of my stay in Iran.
I wanted to commit suicide. Why? Because we had no right to express
dissent. There was no freedom. Even personal things young people
wanted to do like go out to parties or wear makeup or just go
out freely. Many of my friends were burning themselves to die
or becoming addicted to drugs. On the Internet, I came across
a saying of Maryam Rajavi, 'You're capable and you must,' and
I felt after that, that I was also capable. I got my self-confidence.
I always believed women were weak, but when I read Maryam Rajavi's
words, I got the self-confidence to come here.''
I asked her a question to slow her down, but she simply pushed
the pause button in her mind, released it when my question ended,
and the tape rolled on. ''My two brothers were supporters of
the Mujahedeen,'' she said, ''and were executed by the Khomeini
regime.''
Several months ago, she e-mailed the Mujahedeen, who then
facilitated her passage to Turkey, where she was met at the border,
put on a train to Ankara and then Iraq. ''I was educated in courses
of Mujahedeen history, Iranian history and the current political
situation,'' she carried on. ''Now I'm in artillery class.''
She explained what it was like to be in Iraq during the U.S.
bombing. ''I was scared, but I reminded myself that I came to
struggle against fundamentalism, and the fact that I was a member
of the Mujahedeen family gave me strength.'' And then she stopped,
said thank you and went away.
There were three more just like her. ''When I was in Iran,
I didn't think I could drive a tank and shoot a gun, but when
I saw sister Maryam Rajavi, I got hope that I can do everything,''
said Shiva, a 21-year-old tank driver. ''Now that I know Maryam
Rajavi, I want other people to know about her too, because the
freedom of Iran depends on her.''
After the parade of testimonials, I was whisked onto a tank
for a spin around the training ring. The women were giddy, affectionate
and proud of their vehicles. They all told me how much self-confidence
they had gained through Maryam. I had heard that the Mujahedeen
must take a vow of ''eternal divorce,'' that the young ones can
never marry or have children and that the older ones had to divorce
their spouses sometime in the late 1980's. I asked Sima, a woman
in her late 20's, whether she ever regretted making that celibacy
commitment. ''When I feel that I'm getting closer to my goal,''
she shouted in English against the wind, ''it's a more beautiful
feeling than anything else. It's love.'' And what was her goal?
''I have to teach the women in Iran to feel like I feel inside
and rebuild what Khomeini destroyed. He is killing the soul of
every person.'' I noticed that everyone, young and old, at Camp
Ashraf referred in the same programmed way to the regime of Ayatollah
Khomeini as if the charismatic icon of the Iranian revolution
hadn't died 14 years ago. Sima said that whenever she lapsed
into the ''normal girl dreams'' of marriage and children, she
looked around her and said she felt proud. ''In the difficult
situations, I see happiness in the faces of my sisters.''
Nadereh, an Iranian woman who had grown up in Toronto, told
me she had broken off her engagement to come to Iraq. ''I was
living the best life in Toronto,'' she said. ''I was studying
physiotherapy and body mechanics. I had friends and family. But
I was lacking something.'' Then one day in 1998 she lay on her
bed staring at the ceiling, and heard on Iranian TV that Assadollah
Lajevardi, known as the butcher of Evin, the political prison
in Tehran where thousands of Mujahedeen were tortured and executed,
had been assassinated. The Mujahedeen claimed to have carried
out the celebrated operation. ''I couldn't stand it anymore.
I thought, What are you doing for your people?'' Now she drives
a Katyusha rocket truck.
After we stopped and dismounted, I noticed my minder, Madani,
asking the girls what words we had exchanged out there in the
wind. And when he came back, Bahshai picked up her feminist cant
about the ''crimes of the misogynist regime'' in Tehran and how
Maryam paved the way for women to ''qualify for a hegemonic role''
in the army's general staff. As she would say later, ''Women
under Khomeini commit suicide; women here become responsible.''
Though Maryam Rajavi spends most of her time in France or lobbying
in the West, her smiling green eyes stalk Camp Ashraf almost
as ubiquitously as the image of Saddam in Iraq or Khomeini in
Iran. Her photographs in flowery blouses grace bedsides, dining
tables, lecture halls and even tanks. Back in the 1960's, the
founders of the Mujahedeen were students who melded revolutionary
Islam with Marxism, and they were among the few to battle the
shah with weapons. Like other radical students in the 60's, they
rejected bourgeois values, spurned individualism and found respite
in the militarized life of a cause. They were also vehemently
against U.S. involvement in Iran and killed several Americans
working in Tehran. Most of the student leaders -- except Massoud
Rajavi and a few others who were in prison -- were executed in
the 1970's.
After the shah was overthrown in 1979, Rajavi, with his charismatic
style, gathered thousands of followers. He initially supported
Khomeini, but quickly fell out with him and his ring of clerics.
And in 1981, he plotted to bring down the Islamic regime. Rajavi
dispatched his people into the streets of Tehran, and many were
summarily executed. The Mujahedeen detonated a powerful bomb
that killed more than 70 officials in the Iranian theocracy.
(Today's supreme leader, Ali Khamenei, lost the use of his right
arm in one such explosion that year.) In retaliation, thousands
of Mujahedeen members were arrested and then executed or tortured
inside Evin Prison -- including many of today's Mujahedeen commanders
in Iraq.
Rajavi fled to Paris in disguise. There, he established the National
Council of Resistance in Iran, the political umbrella of the
Mujahedeen. In 1986, the French began forging ties with Khomeini
and kicked out Rajavi and his squads of assassins, who ran into
the arms of Saddam Hussein. Hussein had been welcoming the Mujahedeen
for several years. (Many Mujahedeen political supporters did
stay on in France as political refugees.) Rajavi, in return,
betrayed his own countrymen, identifying Iranian military targets
for Iraq to bomb, a move most Iranians will never forgive. Then,
right after the Iran-Iraq cease-fire in 1988, as if orchestrating
the tragic turning point in his own Rajavi Opera, he launched
thousands of his warriors on ''Operation Eternal Light'' across
the border to capture Iranian territory. Two thousand Mujahedeen
fighters -- many of them the parents, husbands and wives of those
who are now in Iraq -- were killed by the Revolutionary Guard.
The coup de grace that metamorphosed the party into something
more like a husband-and-wife-led cult was Massoud's spectacular
theft of his colleague's wife, Maryam. Massoud fell in love with
her and invented an entire political program to elevate her into
a revolutionary queen and to justify her divorce from her husband.
Women should be equal to men, Massoud claimed, and Maryam should
be an equal leader by his side. But working together without
being married would be a violation of Islamic law. So he maneuvered
her divorce and called it a ''cultural revolution.''
As Ervand Abrahamian, a historian and author of ''The Iranian
Mujahedeen,'' told me: ''Rajavi said he was emulating the prophet''
-- Muhammad -- ''who had married his adopted son's wife to show
he could overcome conventional morality. It smacked of blasphemy.''
Rajavi liked having women around him and overhauled the command
structure to replace the men with women -- this time calling
it a ''constitutional revolution.'' It was also politically astute
and added alluring spice for their public-relations campaign
in the West.
"Rajavi, Rajavi, Iran, Iran, Maryam, Maryam, Iran, Iran,''
shouted a dozen young women commandos, trotting with their Kalashnikovs
on a scrubby field, camouflage leaves and twigs bouncing on their
helmets, their faces blurred by green paint. ''Run, run, fire,
fire.'' They rolled, crouched, crept, fired and regrouped around
their commander. One stepped forward: ''We weren't coordinated.''
Another shouted, ''The distance between us was too much.'' Another
shouted, ''Our speed wasn't adequate.'' They were given a rest
and then, spotting me, skipped up on cue, sweating and out of
breath. Nineteen-year-old Sahar began: ''My mother was pregnant
with me when she was arrested, and I was born in Evin Prison
in 1983. When I was 1 year old, my father was executed for supporting
the Mujahedeen. Now I drive a Cascavel. My mother is at another
base. It's one of the reasons I decided to join the army.''
As the leaders like to boast, the Mujahedeen is a family affair.
(''We have three generations of martyrs: grandmothers, mothers,
daughters.'') Most of the girls I was meeting had grown up in
Mujahedeen schools in Ashraf, where they lived separated from
their parents. Family visits were allowed on Thursday nights
and Fridays. When Iraq invaded Kuwait, many of these girls were
transported to Jordan and then smuggled to various countries
-- Germany, France, Canada, Denmark, England, the United States
-- where they were raised by guardians who were usually Mujahedeen
supporters. When they were 18 or 19, many of them decided to
come back to Iraq and fill the ranks of the youngest Mujahedeen
generation. Though ''decided'' is probably not the right word,
since from the day they were born, these girls and boys were
not taught to think for themselves but to blindly follow their
leaders. ''Every morning and night, the kids, beginning as young
as 1 and 2, had to stand before a poster of Massoud and Maryam,
salute them and shout praises to them,'' Nadereh Afshari, a former
Mujahedeen deep-believer, told me. Afshari, who was posted in
Germany and was responsible for receiving Mujahedeen children
during the gulf war, said that when the German government tried
to absorb Mujahedeen children into their education system, the
Mujahedeen refused. Many of the children were sent to Mujahedeen
schools, particularly in France. The Rajavis, Afshari went on
to say, ''saw these kids as the next generation's soldiers. They
wanted to brainwash them and control them.'' Which may explain
the pattern to their stories: a journey to self-empowerment and
the enlightenment of self-sacrifice inspired by the light and
wisdom of Maryam and Massoud.
As we cruised around the grounds, Hossein Madani said: ''Did
you know that they built all this from scratch? That's why the
combatants love their base so much.'' And it was true; the Mujahedeen
had managed to cultivate out of the desert their own little paradise
with vegetable gardens, rows of Eucalyptus and poplar trees,
sports fields and Thursday night movies. When I asked about the
fact that the land -- along with all clothing, ammunition, gas
and the like -- had been donated by Saddam Hussein and that the
Mujahedeen was, in effect, fighting one dictatorship under the
wings of another, both Madani and Bahshai insisted that the Mujahedeen's
precondition for setting up bases in Iraq was independence from
Iraq's affairs. ''All we've used is the soil,'' Bahshai insisted.
Either she was an adept liar or in deep denial, since everyone
I spoke to -- Iraqi intelligence officers, Kurdish commanders
and human rights groups -- said that in 1991 Hussein used the
Mujahedeen and its tanks as advance forces to crush the Kurdish
uprisings in the north and the Shia uprisings in the south. And
former Mujahedeen members remember Maryam Rajavi's infamous command
at the time: ''Take the Kurds under your tanks, and save your
bullets for the Iranian Revolutionary Guards.''
though for years the Mujahedeen preached a Marxist-Islamic ideology,
it has modernized with the times. Today, one of the standard
lines of the Mujahedeen's National Council of Resistance to politicians
in Europe and America is that it is advocating a secular, democratic
government in Iran, and that when it overthrows the regime, it
will set up a six-month interim government with Maryam as president
and then hold free elections. But despite its rhetoric, the Mujahedeen
operates like any other dictatorship. Mujahedeen members have
no access to newspapers or radio or television, other than what
is fed them. As the historian Abrahamian told me, ''No one can
criticize Rajavi.'' And everyone must go through routine self-criticism
sessions. ''It's all done on tape, so they have records of what
you say. If there's sign of resistance, you're considered not
revolutionary enough, and you need more ideological training.
Either people break away or succumb.''
Salahaddin Mukhtadi, an Iranian historian in exile who still
maintains communications with the Mujahedeen because it is the
strongest armed opposition to the Iranian regime, told me that
Mujahedeen members ''are locked up if they disagree with anything.
And sometimes killed.''
Afshari, who fled the group 10 years ago, told me how friendship
was forbidden. No two people could sit alone and talk together,
especially about their former lives. Informants were planted
everywhere. It was Maryam's idea to kill emotional relationships.
''She called it 'drying the base,''' Afshari said. ''They kept
telling us every one of your emotions should be channeled toward
Massoud, and Massoud equals leadership, and leadership equals
Iran.'' The segregation of the sexes began almost from toddlerhood.
''Girls were not allowed to speak to boys. If they were caught
mingling, they were severely punished.''
Though Maryam and Massoud finagled it so they could be together,
they forced everyone else into celibacy. ''They told us, 'We
are at war, and soldiers cannot have wives and husbands,''' Afshari
said. ''You had to report every single day and confess your thoughts
and dreams. They made men say they got erections when they smelled
the perfume of a woman.'' Men and women had to participate in
''weekly ideological cleansings,'' in which they would publicly
confess their sexual desires. It was not only a form of control
but also a means to delete all remnants of individual thought.
One of the most disturbing encounters I had in Ashraf was with
Mahnaz Bazazi, a commander who had been with the Mujahedeen for
25 years. I met her in the Ashraf hospital. Bazazi was probably
on drugs, but that didn't explain the natural intoxication she
was radiating, despite -- or perhaps because -- she had just
had her legs amputated after an American missile slammed into
the warehouse she was guarding. The doctor told me he never heard
her complain. ''Even in this way, she's confronting the Mullahs,''
he said. Bazazi interrupted him. ''This is not me personally,''
she said in a soft high voice. ''These are the ideas of the Mujahedeen.
It's true I lost my legs, but my struggle will continue because
I have a wish -- the freedom of my country.'' At the foot of
her bed, surrounded by candles, stood a large framed photograph
of Maryam in a white dress and blue flowered head scarf.
In the chaotic days after the fall of Baghdad, several Mujahedeen
members managed to flee the military camps and were in Kurdish
custody in northern Iraq. Kurdish officials told me they weren't
sure what to do with them. One was Mohammad, a gaunt 19-year-old
Iranian from Tehran with sad chestnut eyes. He hadn't heard of
the Mujahedeen until one day last year when he was in Istanbul
desperately looking for work. A Mujahedeen recruiter spotted
him and a friend sleeping on the streets, so hungry they couldn't
think anymore. The recruiter gave them a bed and food for the
night, and the next day showed them videos of the Mujahedeen
struggle. He enticed them to join with an offer to earn money
in Iraq while simultaneously fighting the cruel Iranian regime.
What's more, he said, you can marry Mujahedeen girls and start
your own family. The Mujahedeen seemed like salvation. Mohammad
was told to inform his family that he was going to work in Germany
and given an Iraqi passport.
The first month at Ashraf, he said, wasn't so bad. Then came
the indoctrination in the reception department and the weird
self-criticism sessions. He quickly realized there would be no
wives, no pay, no communication with his parents, no friendships,
no freedom. The place was a nightmare, and he wanted out. But
there was no leaving. When he refused to pledge the oath to struggle
forever, he was subjected to relentless psychological pressure.
One night, he couldn't take it anymore. He swallowed 80 diazepam
pills. His friend, he said, slit his wrists. The friend died,
but to Mohammad's chagrin, he woke up in a solitary room. After
days of intense prodding to embrace the Mujahedeen way, he finally
relented to the oath. He trundled along numbly until the Americans
invaded Iraq, when he and another friend managed to slip out
into the desert. They were helped out by Arabs, and then turned
themselves over to the Kurds, hoping for mercy. Mohammad fell
ill, and the next thing he knew he was in prison. ''The Mujahedeen
has a good appearance to the outside world, but anyone who has
lived among them knows how rotten and dirty they are,'' he said.
Another Iranian whom I met at the Kurdish prison told me that
he had been a zealous Mujahedeen supporter for years in Iran,
and when he finally made it to the Iraqi camps, he was horrified
to discover that his dream was a totalitarian mini-state.
Before I left Camp Ashraf, Massoud Farschi, one of the Mujahedeen
spokesmen who was educated in the United States, told me that
he thought the Mujahedeen was in the best position it had ever
been in. ''We've said all along that the real threat in the world
is fundamentalism, and now the world has finally seen that.''
The Mujahedeen, he said, is the barrier to that fundamentalism.
Nevertheless, two days later, in early May, Gen. Ray Odierno
of the Fourth Infantry Division was dispatched to the camp to
negotiate the Mujahedeen's surrender. American tanks were posted
outside Ashraf's gates, and two B-52's were circling the skies
above. After a day of discussion, the Mujahedeen commanders reached
a capitulation agreement in which they would consolidate their
weapons and personnel into two separate camps. Lt. Col. John
Miller, also with the Fourth, attended a ceremony in which the
men and women bid farewell to their tanks. ''We saw folks kissing
their vehicles, hugging them,'' he said. One 50-year-old man
broke down in front of them, wailing. The women, he said, were
much more controlled. Not so the women in Europe, who until recently
were crying on the streets for the release of their beloved Maryam.
They got their wish; a court ordered her released on bail. As
for Massoud Rajavi, he has not uttered a peep. In fact, he seems
to have disappeared. Some Iraqis claim to have seen him a few
days before Baghdad fell boarding a helicopter south of the capital.
After the negotiations with the Mujahedeen, it was reported that
Odierno said he thought that the group's commitment to democracy
in Iran meant its status as a terrorist organization should be
reviewed. There are also Senate staff members, Pentagon officials
and even some people in the State Department who have said that
if all the Mujahedeen is doing is fighting the ''evil regime''
in Iran, it quite likely that it will be removed from the State
Department's terrorist list. ''There is a move afoot among Pentagon
hard-liners,'' one administration official said, ''to use them
as an opposition in the future.'' Recently Brownback submitted
an Iran Democracy Act modeled on the Iraqi Liberation Act, which
would set aside $50 million to help opposition groups overthrow
the regime. The Mujahedeen, their U.S. supporters say, has provided
the United States with key intelligence on Iran's nuclear program.
One Congressional staff member working close to the issue said
that there was a national security directive circulating ''that
includes a proposal for limited surgical strikes against the
Iranian regime's nuclear facilities. We would be remiss if we
did not use the Mujahedeen to identify exactly what the Iranians
have and in the longer term, to facilitate regime change.''
Meanwhile, inside Iran, the street protesters risking their lives
and disappearing inside the regime's prisons consider the Mujahedeen
a plague -- as toxic, if not more so, than the ruling clerics.
After all, the Rajavis sold out their fellow Iranians to Saddam
Hussein, trading intelligence about their home country for a
place to house their Marxist-Islamist Rajavi sect. While Mujahedeen
press releases were pouring out last month, taking undue credit
for the nightly demonstrations, many antigovernment Iranians
were rejoicing over the arrest of Maryam Rajavi and wondering
where Massoud was hiding and why he, too, hadn't been apprehended.
This past winter in Iran, when such a popular outburst among
students and others was still just a dream, if you mentioned
the Mujahedeen, those who knew and remembered the group laughed
at the notion of it spearheading a democracy movement. Instead,
they said, the Rajavis, given the chance, would have been the
Pol Pot of Iran. The Pentagon has seen the fatal flaw of hitching
itself to volatile groups like the Islamists who fought the Soviets
in Afghanistan and, more recently, the Iraqi exile groups who
had no popular base at home. It seems dangerously myopic that
the U.S. is even considering resurrecting the Rajavis and their
army of Stepford wives.
Elizabeth Rubin is a frequent contributor to the magazine. Her
last article was about political reformers in Iran. (New York
Times Magazine Section, 7.13.03) |